Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Meritocracy

Meritocracy is a recurring theme in social sciences and especially in sociology. In a simplified or explained way, this concept indicates that the social position of each depends on their merits or effort. That is, positions of social power are a consequence of people's efforts. With this idea, however, we do not limit ourselves to the description, as if social organization were meritocratic, it would also be just at the same time, because what would be in the most powerful positions would be the ones that have made the effort. They are therefore beliefs or ideologies.

Does anyone believe that society is meritocratic? If it is not enough to look at the environment, most of the works on the subject clearly show that people do not believe that society is meritocratic, since their daily experiences demonstrate the opposite: the ways of permanence in the positions of command, and the paths, almost always have little relation to the effort. Evidently, in academic studies they are also marginal views, usually as ideological provocation. However, the concept remains important in the social sciences, if not applied in its entirety to society, in relation to more concrete areas, especially education.

In the sociology of education there is much talk about the meritocracy issue. Paradoxically, contrary to what happens in society as a whole, the educational system is generally related to effort and merit in a relatively natural and uncritical way. What is my academic trajectory, if not the result of my effort or my laziness? Of course, the individual effort in the process a person may have at school is an important variable, but other forces and factors, often covertly, also influence. In other words, as we see more clearly when talking about society, neither everyone in education should make the same effort to achieve similar results.

People do not believe that societies are meritocratic: the ways of being in command positions are almost always unrelated to effort.

Among the hundreds, thousands, of works that have studied the exchange between meritocracy and school in the sociology of education and in other disciplines, I will quote that of the social scientist Paul Willis, who is Learning to Labour: In the ethnographic work How Working Class Kids Get Working Class Jobs (Learning to Work: How Working-Class Kids Get Working Class Jobs), in the 1970s, he looked at the topic that appears in the title itself at a low-class school in the UK. The author highlighted, along with many other aspects, the reproduction of the socioeconomic inequality that occurs at school. Students, rather than participating in a clear game about knowledge according to their merits, were assuming the social position they would occupy in the future, according to the author's long study.

The truth is that in the sociology of education we are in favour of repeating the idea of reproduction of inequality, perhaps because it seems to us that it is not said otherwise. And yet it is also true that the education system is an important instrument for equality. The school shares both characteristics, reproduction and transformation. But, as we are talking about meritocracy today, it should be noted that the educational system has become the last strength of meritocratic ideology, and this perspective is far from fair.

Bidali zure iritzi artikuluak iritzia@argia.eus helbide elektronikora

ARGIAk ez du zertan bat etorri artikuluen edukiarekin. Idatzien gehienezko luzera 4.500 karakterekoa da (espazioak barne). Idazkera aldetik gutxieneko zuzentasun bat beharrezkoa da: batetik, ARGIAk ezin du hartu zuzenketa sakona egiteko lanik; bestetik, egitekotan edukia nahi gabe aldatzeko arriskua dago. ARGIAk azaleko zuzenketak edo moldaketak egingo dizkie artikuluei, behar izanez gero.


You are interested in the channel: Iritzia
Spreading hate, racism and xenophobia in mailboxes

After the beginning of the rehabilitation work of the Reception Center for International Protection in the Arana neighborhood of Vitoria-Gasteiz, we have seen the need to reposition ourselves publicly as occupied and concerned neighbors and to make the Basque Country a true host... [+]


It's for your benefit.
Seeing how many psychologists, doctors, therapists... share miraculous methods, one can think that the education of children is an international concern and that we have all become experts.

The solution is not technical, it is social; the answer to Arnaldo Otegi
In recent weeks, the debate on renewable energies has been spreading in the media. In the Basque Country, we first had the media case of the attack suffered by Aritz Ochandiano, whom he attributed to his support for renewable energies; a few days later, the great blackout, and... [+]

Lack of commitment of the Department of Territorial Green Balance of the DFS
The name doesn't actually preserve the being. The paper is not enough, although the paper holds everything. Until it gets wet. This is the case with the Department of Territorial Green Balance of the Provincial Council of Gipuzkoa. In fact, he has renounced what the name should... [+]

War on the imperialist war

A few weeks ago, the President of the European Union, Ursula von der Leyen, reported on the need for military spending of eight hundred billion euros. This expenditure is said to be in response to a military threat to which Europe is exposed, and it has been confirmed that there... [+]


Publish some data, hide the entire result

The Department of Education reported on diagnostic evaluations in February: He talked about the mid-stage of 2023 and the end-stage of 2024. Since the disastrous results would show that we have a structural problem, the department decided to comply with the procedure (publish... [+]


About the Item

Totally dedicated to the tendency of dispersion that we carry in the genes that I was walking down the street, in some useless abstraction that distracts you from the physical and curricular paths. A girl who hasn't turned thirty before. Something fell out of his pocket. The girl... [+]


2025-05-07 | Inma Errea Cleix
Recycling the Life

I have to clean two different places at the same time. Not an ordinary cleanliness, but something that forces us to explore in a different way the landscapes that surround us in our day to day, which also makes us move the structures within ourselves along with the external... [+]


Nola iritsi gara honaino?

Bilboko Kafe Antzokian, hemen argitaratutako nire kolaborazioen bilduma den Zapalduon pedagogia liburuaren aurkezpenean, entzuleen arteko emakume batek bota zidan galdera. Ohikoak ditudan gaiak aletuz joana nintzen hitzaldian, eta Euskal Herriaren egungo egoeraren kezka jada... [+]


Poker, Chess and Go game

Professor Jeffrey Sachs of Columbia University is interviewed by Yanis Varoufakis on the DiEM25 movement’s YouTube channel. This explains that in international politics the United States of America plays poker, Russia plays chess and the Chinese play Go. The latter was... [+]


The technology
Living in illusion

Last week, during the blackout, seeing ourselves vulnerable, we began to investigate many people in order to understand what happened: how does the infrastructure that transports electricity work? Why is it getting old? I am fascinated by the physical phenomenon of electricity... [+]


2025-05-07 | Ula Iruretagoiena
Lurraldea eta arkitektura
Euskadi industriala

Euskadi markak, eraikuntza sektoreko ekonomiaren  estrategian, “industrializazioa” mantrarako hitz gisa hartu duela jakinarazi berri du Eusko Jaurlaritzak. Etxebizitza publikoaren eraikuntzan industrializaturiko prozesu eta elementuak lan guztien %65a izatea... [+]


2025-05-07 | June Fernández
Seller of melon
Points of Interest

The pandemic has revealed, in all its crudeness, the consequences of the neoliberal model of care for the elderly, children and the dependent population. Now is the time to consolidate the critical discourses and community alternatives that flourished during the lockdown.”... [+]


The Blackout
I don't know if we've been blinded by the blackout or if we've been extinguished because we're blind. In any case, the blackout is not a hysterical – sorry, historical – event that began and ended today. I think it started a long time ago and unfortunately it didn’t end on St... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude