Goodbye ETA; Stop the Suffering

  • We went through a cathartic process on October 20th, 2011, when they renounced violence, but now, too, writing that ETA has disappeared is no small thing. When you realise everything that means, a shiver goes down your spine. There have been too many events and feelings, too much suffering over the last 60 years for it to be otherwise.


2018ko maiatzaren 11n - 11:29

If ETA had announced its end on May 3rd, 1979, on the eve of the referendum which accepted the Gernika Statute, it would have happened in a very different way, it would have gone down in history in a different way: a historical guerilla organisation, founded to combat the Franco regime set up in 1936 and to recover the Basque nation's rights, members of ETA would have been almost heroes… Well, who knows, but something like that could well have happened. When they killed Carrero Blanco, who was to have been Franco's successor, in 1973, people sang “Voló, voló, Carrero voló” (“He flew, he flew, Carrero flew”) in the streets, and it was no joke.

If ETA has dissolved in 1989, after the Algeria negotiations, it would still have had something of that appearance, and ETA members in prison and exile would have been back home long ago thanks to the results of political negotiation. If the basis of the Lizarra-Garazi agreement of 1999 had not closed the doors to it, perhaps a generous national agreement would have been possible; and if it had stopped during the negotiations at Loiola in 2006, ETA might have been able to run to catch the last train. But what had sprung up as a popular movement had got lost in the avant-garde and completely lost touch with the people.

Political Struggle

During this whole process, and on many other occasions, the Spanish State used the word "never" in connection with speaking with terrorists – the political party being UCD, PSOE or PP – whenever political issues arose. José María Aznar saying “The Basque Liberation Movement”, and with that euphemism admitting that he had given permission for talks with ETA, has its place in history. But the armed organisation lost that bilateral opportunity, and since then it has had to act unilaterally, and without achieving a single one of its objectives. We can at least admit that it has been skilful in doing so: it could have gone much worse, and there are many examples of that around the world.

The winners usually write history, and the Spanish State has often won, although not as much as the PP would like; for instance, in the Basque Country its narrative will be insignificant.

But now the struggle for how to tell its history will start: were they just terrorists? Good terrorists? Mistaken fighters? Heroes? The winners usually write history, and the Spanish State has often won, although not as much as the PP would like; for instance, in the Basque Country its narrative will be insignificant. The repression it has carried out, on the other hand, is far from insignificant, and it conditions things considerably, particularly when it has allies such as the right-wing Basque party EAJ, which is extremely skilful as swapping political ethics for money, for instance with regard to the suspension of autonomy in Catalonia, and during the gradual Basque peace process.

National Rights

ETA was founding in 1959 in response to violations of national rights, its aim being to enable those rights through armed struggle. It has not achieved that, but that does not mean it has had no influence in that area; seen from today's perspective, it is still too early to say whether it is affecting today's political situation. More time will have to go by before we can say that and, in all probability, the answer will depend on who the history is written by.

ETA has not achieved its historical objectives, but it was founded as the consequence of a political problem, and the problems which Basque society has with the Spanish and French states have not gone away. During the last phase of the armed struggle we have lived through the national problem has been very clear, and just as intense as it was during the 1936 Spanish war and during the 19th century Carlist wars. In the future making sure that such things never happen again will be our greatest challenge and that inevitably requires a political agreement between Basque citizens. That will be followed by agreement with the Spanish and French states, which will have to be based on Basque citizens' democratic will.

Type of Violence

Obviously, it would have been much better for such things never to have happened, but they did, and each one of ETA's steps over the last 60 years will have to seen and examined in its historical context. Violence and violations in no way improve depending on the number of people who are in favour of them happening. Whether they are legal or not (which is the crux for differentiating between war and terrorism), it would have been better for people never to have caused them to happen regardless of whether that violence is legal or not.

Another matter is where each of us categories ETA's violence, but, seeing the world as it is at the moment, and seeing how states are using all sorts of violence, unilateral moral judgements about violence are out of place.

But violence is part of us. There will be more opportunities to talk about violence, especially when there are appropriate conditions to do so, but violence used to repress people and nations and trample on their freedom and violence used to obtain freedom are chalk and cheese. Another matter is where each of us categories ETA's violence, but, seeing the world as it is at the moment, and seeing how states are using all sorts of violence, unilateral moral judgements about violence are out of place. Even more so in this case, in which Basque left-wing patriots are the only ones being asked to be self-critical.

Another period for analysis, self-criticism and reflection starts now, and all three of those exercises are necessary. But there are other urgent needs to, and the most important one of all it is to realise that people are still suffering today: prisoners and people in exile, their families, and all sorts of victims of violence. Above all, we should distrust political processes which are not based on people. Now responsibility for those groups of people should be the fundamental basis for politics during negotiations about the Basque statue, during demonstrations, and in all types of political agreements.

Furthermore, the “Problem” has finished, so let problems come as a result of merciless neoliberalism; the problems which standardise us with every other people in Europe.


Irakurrienak
Matomo erabiliz
Azoka
Kanal honetatik interesatuko zaizu: English
2023-01-18 | ARGIA
ARGIA: Worker-Owned Basque centenary Media
Independent journalism with solidarity-based subscription model

ARGIA is a news media funded in 1919 in Pamplona and published in Basque language. At first religious – called Zeruko Argia, "light of heaven” –, forbidden during the fascist dictatorship in Spain from 1936 on, in the 1950s and 1960s it had managed to come... [+]


2020-02-07 | Paul Iano
The future of the Basque economy: labor power or tech parasites

In this series of articles, it should now have become clear that venture capital has created a system in which two types of companies become global giants: companies with bad business models but good marketing, or good business models and horrible impacts on society. This... [+]


2020-01-29 | Paul Iano
The Coming Tech Economy
The creative destruction of peer to peer

One of the confusing aspects of the tech industry is that from a distance all the companies can seem the same. They use apps, have similar design styles, are based in hip urban centers, and strangely have millions of dollars without making any money. In part, this series is... [+]


2020-01-16 | Paul Iano
The reason Telepizza won't pay minimum wage: Undercover again

After publishing Glovolizacion, a three-month undercover investigation into the working conditions of Glovo riders, I received almost entirely positive feedback from the general public and riders alike. Most riders felt ignored and exploited, and most readers were interested in... [+]


2019-07-21 | Paul Iano
Who is Glovo?

This is the third in a four-part investigative series examining Glovo’s business model and its relationship with the world it operates. Based on public statements by Glovo’s founders, this article will contextualize their world-view and the changes they hope to... [+]


Eguneraketa berriak daude