Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Result of the insistence: road signs in Basque

  • The citizen is asking for signs to be put in Basque. The Government responds that this is not required by law. The Observatory replies that, although the law does not oblige, it is not forbidden to place in Basque. The Government maintains its position. However, the population is engaged and the media are pressing. Thus, in some cases, changes occur; in Navarre, signs are also placed in Basque.

13 September 2024 - 13:39
Bide gorriko seinalea gaztelaniaz eta euskaraz, Behatokiak eskaera egin eta gero. Argazkia: Behatokia.

The Behatokia Linguistic Rights Observatory has published the summary of the month of August, as it does every month. Violations of language rights, congratulations and achievements are on the list. There is an achievement that says that in most signs of the road between Pamplona and Zizur Mayor have incorporated the Basque country. One citizen contacted the Observatory. He denounced that there was no Basque in those signs.

This is not the first time that the Centre has received a complaint of this kind, and on the other hand, the response given by the Government of Navarra in these cases is practically the same. The director of the Centre, Agurne Gaubeka, has explained the context to us to see how the Government of Navarra responds to the question of signals. Several articles of Decree 103/2017 were repealed in 2019. One of them said that the signals, warnings, notifications… of the central services of the Government of Navarra should be bilingual. This article was declared null and void by the courts. Thus, using this annulment, the Government responds to the forms of denunciation by the citizen of Zizur, who has no obligation to do so in bilingual. The Centre repeatedly responds that there is no obligation, but there is no prohibition: “The Government can and seems to have to do so, at least they should be bilingual.” In Gaubeka's view, insistence sometimes has consequences. In Zizur’s example, the answer did not promise much change, but the very citizen who denounced the situation has told the Observatory that almost all the signs have become bilingual. In the opinion of Gaubeka, the pressure of the public and the media influences, and that is why: “We appeal to the citizens, sometimes neither in the first, nor in the second… we get it in the third, but we manage to make changes and encourage people to send us pictures [to the Euskera Phone].

The sign is still in Spanish. Photo: Observatory.

 


You are interested in the channel: Behatokia
Report 2023 on linguistic infringements of the Centre
Same linguistic limits and violations for ten years
In 2023, the Observatory received 909 complaints related to violations of language rights. Over 75% of them refer to services related to administration: “Citizens report that every year they continue to fight the same wall.”

The Government of Navarra refuses to implement Lerín's Model D, although the number of applications is legally sufficient
Several parents of Lerín requested last year the opening of line D in the public school of the town, but despite exceeding the minimum number of requests marked by law, the parents will not have this possibility, according to the Government of Navarra, “because the school of... [+]

Irun City Hall forced participants to do so in Spanish for political reasons
Kepa Ordoki - Memoria Histórico Bidasoan denounces that the organization told them that in the talk they would have to speak in Spanish "for political reasons". The Observatory on Linguistic Rights regards this as "very serious".

2023-02-10 | Lide Iraola
Chronicle
A right of all
Language rights have appeared in the headlines more than usual in recent times, although they have not announced good news. The courts have rejected language profiling in various jobs serving citizens. Agurne Gaubeka, director of the Observatory on Linguistic Rights, visited... [+]

2023-01-09 | ARGIA
The Centre has known in December the 16 violations of language rights
Like every month, the Observatory on Linguistic Rights has taken up the violations, congratulations and achievements of the rights of December. Most of the infringements come from both private companies and public institutions, such as the non-guarantee of the Basque health... [+]

2023-01-05 | Lide Iraola
The Observatory claims that guaranteeing Euskera is a matter of "social justice" in relation to the Barakaldo ruling
The Observatory on Linguistic Rights denounces that access to public services in Basque is a basic collective right and considers it serious that the High Court of Justice of the Basque Country has prevented the City of Barakaldo from requesting Euskera in public services. On... [+]

2022-11-22 | ARGIA
Beginning in Pamplona the campaign “Municipalities with me in Basque” to identify and denounce violations of linguistic rights
The cultural groups of the Basque Country of Pamplona and the Observatory of Linguistic Rights have launched the campaign "The Municipalities with me in Basque" with the aim of highlighting the violations of the linguistic rights of the City of Pamplona. For this purpose, they ask... [+]

2022-10-03 | ARGIA
A sample of violations of language rights in September
In September, the Observatory on Linguistic Rights published the complaints, congratulations and achievements of citizens.  

2022-07-27 | ARGIA
Amendments to the Decree of Merits for admission to the Administration of Navarra to alleviate the "exclusion"
On July 6, the Government of Navarre made available to citizens the Decree of Merit Assessment for the Entry and Provision of Jobs in the Public Administrations of Navarra. The proposal submitted by the Council of Euskalgintza and the Observatory on Linguistic Rights has been... [+]

2022-07-04 | ARGIA
Ekaineko hizkuntza eskubideen urraketak, Behatokiaren eskutik
Gurutzetako ospitaleko errotulazioa, Lanbideren webgunea, Hirigune Elkargoko gutuna frantsesez ikastoletara...

Hizkuntz Eskubideen Behatokiak publikatu egin ditu ekainean erregistratu dituen eskubide urraketak eta zorion mezuak.


The Observatory on Linguistic Rights warns of the risk of perpetuating infringements of language rights in public services
The Observatory on Linguistic Rights presented the report The Situation of Linguistic Rights 2021 at an event held last week at the Europe Palace in Vitoria-Gasteiz. It warned of the risk of perpetuating infringements of language rights in public services. In 2021, the... [+]

2022-01-20 | Leire Artola Arin
UEMAk eta Behatokiak Nafarroako Gobernuari eskatu diote administrazioko tramite elektronikoak euskaratzeko

Herritarren hizkuntza eskubideak errespetatzeko neurriak galdegin dituzte. Gaur egun administrazioan telematikoki egin daitezkeen tramiteen %23 soilik egin daitezke euskaraz, eta tokiko erakundeen kasuan %2,5 besterik ez.


2021-11-11 | Leire Artola Arin
Council and Observatory denounce the lack of "ambition" of the Basque Navarro plan
The Government ' s proposed plan has been amended 67 times. They criticize the fact that no regulatory changes have been made and that this is a "perpetuation of rights violations".

Eguneraketa berriak daude